Joe’S New York Pizzeria Menu

At Joe’s New York Pizzeria Menu, you’ll find a delicious mix of classic New York-style pizza, fresh pasta, and savory appetizers that’ll have your taste buds dancing. Whether you're in the mood for a crispy, thin-crust pizza topped with your favorite ingredients or you want to try something new like their specialty pies, there's something here for everyone. Located in the heart of Canastota at 200 S Peterboro St, it's the perfect spot to grab a bite with friends or family.

Beyond pizza, Joe’s menu boasts a variety of pasta dishes, subs, and wings, each made with quality ingredients that bring out the authentic flavors of the Big Apple. Whether you go for the creamy pasta Alfredo or a hearty meatball sub, every dish is crafted to satisfy. Their selection of appetizers, from mozzarella sticks to garlic bread, pairs perfectly with any meal, setting the stage for an unforgettable dining experience.

Appetizers

Small Garlic Bread
US$1.55
Large Garlic Bread
US$3.05
Small Garlic Bread w/ Cheese
US$2.05
Large Garlic Bread w/ Cheese
US$3.55
Mozzarella Sticks
US$7.00
Onion Rings
US$6.45
Jalapeno Poppers
6 Poppers per order
US$6.95
Chicken Fingers
4 Chicken Tenders per order
US$7.45
French Fries
US$3.95
Combo Platter
Mixed fried foods
US$10.00
Fried Ravioli
6 Raviolis per order
US$7.45
Garlic Knots
6 Knots per order
US$3.75
Small Tossed Salad
US$6.50
Large Tossed Salad
US$7.50
Small Antipasto Salad
US$8.00
Large Antipasto Salad
US$10.00
Small Tuna Salad
US$8.00
Large Tuna Salad
US$10.00
Small Crispy Chicken Salad
US$9.00
Large Crispy Chicken Salad
US$11.00

Specialty Pizza (Prices Vary by Pizza Size, Prices Start as a Small Pizza)

Vegetable Delight
US$22.15
Broccoli & Three Cheese
US$19.70
Popeye
US$18.70
Chicken Wing
US$20.15
White Broccoli Pizza
US$19.70
Chicken Bacon Ranch
US$19.70
The Dickie Diveronica
US$21.15
Garlic Pizza
US$15.70
Supreme
US$22.15
The Carmen Basilio
US$20.15
Bacon Lettuce and Tomato
US$19.70
Hawaiian Pizza
US$18.70
The Billy Backus
US$25.15
Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
US$21.15
El Diablo
US$19.15
Sienna
US$20.15
Quattro Formaggio
US$20.15
Bianca Pizza
US$20.15
Mama D's Delight
US$22.15
Rustica Pizza
US$20.15
Tomato Bacon Ranch
US$20.20
Upside Down
US$15.70

Specialty Items (Prices May Vary in Size, Prices Start as a Small)

Stromboli Roll
US$21.45
Stuffed Pizza
US$21.45
Personal Calzone
US$11.00
Square Sicilian Pizza
US$19.25
Gluten Free Pizza
US$14.70

Dinners

Manicotti
US$12.50
Ravioli
US$12.50
Stuffed Shells
US$12.50
Spaghetti
US$12.50
Baked Ziti
US$12.50
Homemade Lasagna
US$12.50
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
US$12.50
Eggplant Parmigiana
US$12.50
Side of Spaghetti
US$2.25
Side of Meatball or Sausage
US$2.25

Cold Subs

Small Turkey Sub
US$8.50
Large Turkey Sub
US$9.50
Small Ham Sub
US$8.50
Large Ham Sub
US$9.50
Small Salami Sub
US$8.50
Large Salami Sub
US$9.50
Small Italian Hero
US$8.50
Large Italian Hero
US$9.50
Small Pepperoni Sub
US$8.50
Large Pepperoni Sub
US$9.50
Small Tuna Sub
US$8.50
Large Tuna Sub
US$9.50

Hot Subs

Small Meatball Tunnel
US$8.50
Large Meatball Tunnel
US$9.50
Small Sausage Tunnel
US$8.50
Large Sausage Tunnel
US$9.50
Small Steak Sub
US$8.50
Large Steak Sub
US$9.50
Small Chicken Parmigiana
US$8.50
Large Chicken Parmigiana
US$9.50
Small Eggplant Parmigiana
US$8.50
Large Eggplant Parmigiana
US$9.50
Small Chicken Deluxe
US$8.50
Large Chicken Deluxe
US$9.50

Desserts

(1) Cannoli
US$2.50
(6) Cannoli
US$12.00

Wings (Prices Vary by Order of Wings, Increments by 10)

10 Wings
US$14.30
10 Boneless Wings
US$9.40
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available.